Oakstone vs. HORL: Is the $350 German Sharpener Worth It for Aussie Cooks?

When you start searching for a premium rolling knife sharpener in Australia, one name inevitably comes up: HORL. With its German engineering and sleek design, it has set a high benchmark in kitchens around the world. But with a price tag that can push past $350 AUD on Amazon, many Aussie home cooks are left wondering: is it really worth it, and is there a smarter alternative?

This is an honest comparison for the passionate home cook who values quality but also seeks genuine value. While we have immense respect for German craftsmanship, we designed Oakstone from the ground up to offer an elite sharpening experience that makes more sense for Australian kitchens.

Let's break down the comparison.

What Makes HORL a Premium Choice?

There's no denying the quality of the HORL sharpener. Its key strengths lie in its "Made in Germany" provenance, which immediately signals precision and reliability to many consumers. The use of high-quality woods like walnut and oak, combined with effective diamond and ceramic abrasives, results in a tool that performs exceptionally well. It’s a beautifully made product with a strong brand reputation, and for those for whom budget is no issue, it's a fantastic choice.

The Aussie Alternative: What is Oakstone?

We created Oakstone to fill a specific gap in the market. We wanted to deliver the same tier of performance and premium feel, but without the premium price tag that often comes with European imports. We focused on the features that matter most to home cooks.

Uncompromising Materials: We chose solid oak for its timeless beauty and robust durability, paired with food-grade 304 stainless steel for all core components. Our brand rule is simple: no plastic parts, no veneers, no shortcuts.
Performance as Standard: We engineered our sharpener with three powerful N50 neodymium magnets to provide an unwavering grip on the blade - addressing a key weakness in many cheaper rolling sharpeners. Our dual-grit system, with a #400 diamond and #1000 ceramic disc, is designed for a complete and effective sharpening and honing process right out of the box.

The Head-to-Head: Performance, Materials, and Value

So, how do they stack up?

Materials: Both brands use high-quality wood. HORL is often seen with a darker walnut, while Oakstone uses classic, solid oak. Aesthetically, it's a matter of preference, but both feel far superior to the generic, lightweight wood or plastic found on budget models.
Performance: Both systems will give you a fantastic edge. The key difference in user experience often comes down to the magnet strength and abrasive quality. By making N52 magnets a standard feature, Oakstone ensures a level of blade stability and safety that is absolutely critical for consistent results.
Price & Value: This is the most significant difference. The HORL 2 Oak sharpener is priced around $350 AUD on Amazon Australia. The Oakstone sharpener is positioned to provide what we believe is an equivalent premium experience for a much more accessible price. For the vast majority of home cooks, the performance is identical for all practical purposes. The question then becomes one of value: why pay more than double for a brand name when you can get an Aussie-born tool of equivalent craftsmanship and performance for less?

Is Oakstone just a HORL copy?

No. While we admire great design, Oakstone was developed independently with the Australian home cook in mind. We made specific engineering choices, like prioritising powerful N50 magnets and solid oak construction as standard, to create a tool that offers the best possible performance and long-term value.

What's the main reason to choose Oakstone over HORL in Australia?

Value. Oakstone offers what we believe is a directly comparable premium sharpening experience - from the high-quality materials to the flawless, consistent edge - at a more sensible price point for the home kitchen. It’s an accessible premium, without compromise.

Can I get replacement discs for my Oakstone sharpener?

Yes. We believe a legacy tool should be serviceable. Replacement diamond and ceramic discs will be available to ensure your Oakstone sharpener lasts for decades, addressing a common frustration users have with other brands where replacement parts are hard to find.

Did you like this article? Spread the word!